wes-hicks-MEL-jJnm7RQ-unsplash
panko gelev

panko gelev

Fender Play vs Yousician

Learning guitar is fun, finding the right learning path – not so much.

These days learning guitar, much like any other skill, can be very accessible and affordable. All you need is a guitar and a desire to play, and, of course, an internet connection. Thanks to the internet, the options are endless, so it is essential to make the right choice that suits you. Choosing the wrong course or instructor can cost you your will to learn. 

But with so many good and well known online guitar lessons sites, the battle between them for the top is enormous. For a new site to prove itself in the market along with sites like GuitarTricks, GuitarJamz or JamPlay, it needs to bring something new and different.

An example of this is Fender Play and Yousician.

But what do they have that helps them compete with the big players?

Finding the right app – focusing on what’s important

All guitar learning modes that do not include direct contact with a live instructor fall into the self-learning category. On the student part, this means that to succeed in learning guitar, you will need to put in a lot of dedication and effort. And on the site part, it means they need to make the lessons engaging, easy to follow, and engaging.

So you need to be careful where and how your guitar story will start.

Fender Play and Yousician are good examples of a self-learning platform.

But what is it that makes them good?

Lessons for beginners

In almost all guitar lessons online sites, beginner lessons are the most important because beginners make the largest group of users. It applies to both Fender Play and Yousician. They offer good lessons for beginners, but after going to the next level, these two are not a very good option.

Cost

Be careful when purchasing these products because sometimes the free trial is not enough to assess whether the program will meet your needs. So the best option to get started is a monthly membership. It is especially true for Yousician where annual memberships cannot be canceled.

Devices

They have one thing in common – they are designed for portable devices such as tablets, Ipad, Android, and iPhone. They are compatible with almost all devices. It’s quite useful if you’re always traveling even when you are at home but don’t want to sit in front of the computer and practice. 

What Fender Play and Yousician have to offer

Fender Play is an app made to the profile of most of the excellent online sites. You won’t find anything groundbreaking at its core because all of these self-learning sites are built on the same foundation. It’s good because the system works, but at the same time, there’s a factor that makes Fender Play special.

The application is organized into paths for every type of instrument and genre. So it is straightforward to track your progress. Also, you can change the path without losing the progress on the previous path.

It is the strongest side of Fender Play. The fact that’s tracking your progress is easy and gives you a sense of accomplishment. At the same time, it knows what is left to learn. 

Pros.

  • Good for beginners
  • Excellently designed app
  • Easy to follow lessons
  • Separate paths for ukulele, acoustic and electric guitar

Cons.

  • Lack of different genre paths (jazz, funk, reggae, metal, etc.)
  • Short song list
  • No advanced lessons

Yousician is a bit different. This application is a balance between lessons and games. The realized idea of turning the guitar into a game controller makes Yousician one of a kind.

The beginner program that Yousician has is one of the best because it does not allow skipping lessons until each level is mastered. This is a great way to make actual progress and to make sure the lesson is learned.

Pros.

  • Perfect for beginners
  • Instant feedback
  • Multi instruments bass guitar, keyboards, ukulele, vocal
  • Works on every type of device

Cons.

  • Not enough video lessons
  • Short song list
  • No intermediate or advanced lessons
  • Lack of different genres 

Beginner or advanced guitarist, Is Fender Play or Yousician the right learning platform for you?

What makes Fender Play and Yousician the best product?

The target group of Fender Play and Yousician (as well as most of the non-formal guitar learning sites) are the beginners. This group of users is very popular because creating lessons is quite easy when using the right method. Plus not to mention that it is the largest group of guitar learners. 

The lessons are mainly learning the first notes, simple melodies, chords, and songs. The way this is all organized work similarly in both apps.

Paths

Once you turn on the Fender Play app, there are four options – electric, acoustic and bass guitar and ukulele. After choosing an instrument, the next step is to select the style you want to learn. Here you got Rock, Blues, Funk (only for the bass track), Pop, Folk, and Country.

Compared to competitors like GuitarTricks or TrueFire, the choice of genres is very limited. It is enough to start learning guitar, but not if you want to be a more advanced player or learn something extra.

The situation with Yousician is similar. After choosing a guitar as the instrument you want to study, three paths follow – Lead, Rhythm, and Knowledge.

They start with the simplest lessons that unlock the next levels through the scoring system. For example, the first two lessons in the Lead Path are Play Strings and Play Frets. It is like a tutorial so users can learn principles on how the application works and move on to the next levels.

Tracking progress

Fender Play has five levels to make things easy to follow; there are bars at the bottom of the screen that shows lessons on how much progress you’ve made. Having many lessons to complete is very interesting and takes a long time.

With each subsequent level, the lessons become more complicated, depending on the level of difficulty. What makes Fender Play mostly suitable for beginners and not intermediate and advanced players. It’s a fact that between the subsequent lessons there isn’t much difference difficulty wise so that progress can be limited.

Below the video of the song lessons, you will find info, chords, tabs, related videos, and tools that make learning easier. The tools section has a tuner, rhythm (play along with drum beats) that serves as a metronome, different chord alternatives, and scales.

When it comes to tracking progress, Yousician is tougher. It does not allow skipping lessons without passing the skill test after each section. The tools sections consist of video lessons, training exercises, and songs.

At the start of the application, there is a question about how much time can you spend on practicing guitar. The options are Quick – 10min, Casual – 20min, Intense – 30min.

With this and the speed of advancement, the application proposes future lessons that will suit each user individually.

But this is one of the indications for what kind of guitarist Yousician is targeting. For any advanced guitarist, 30 min of practice is hardly enough for warm-up exercises.

Song list

The Fender Play song selection is robust. They’re filtered by instruments (guitar, bass guitar, ukulele), type (song, riff) and genres (rock, country, pop, blues, and folk) arranged in alphabetical order.

Normally, with the app being for beginners only, most of the playlist is made up of easy songs with few exceptions.

 Yousician can’t boast with a great song list. The significant disadvantage is that songs from the song lists are not in the original version. They are made as covers by Yousician musicians and are modified and intended mainly for lecture purposes only.

The song selection is poor, so most of them are not classics and are not songs to play with friends or at a gig.

Worse, the option of uploading songs made by the users that made up the most significant and most exciting part of the application was abolished. The same goes for the exercises; there are not very engaging and can sometimes be dull.

Price

One of the main things that make up all the online lessons sites and apps is the free trial. Fender Play has a 14-day free trial that’s enough to look at the app and see if it’s worth buying. To activate the 14 days free trial, you need to enter a credit card that often gets negative reviews from users. Therefore if you think Fender Play is not for you, you should be careful about canceling before your free trial expires. So they will not charge you for your first mount of membership.

The cost of a monthly membership is $9.99, which is twice as cheap as most guitar lessons online. The price is fair if you consider the content of Fender Play compared to sites like GuitarTricks, TrueFire, JamPlay, etc.

Annual membership is $89.99. The price is not that high, but the deal with the annual membership is that considering the limited material Fender Play has to offer. A year is way too long to take advantage of the site. You will be better off with a few months worth of subscription. 

The free trial at Yousician is seven days and can’t be activated without a credit card. Similar to Fender Play, if you are not satisfied within the first seven days, then make sure to cancel it on time. Else you’re going to end up paying for the first month.

If you are only interested in one instrument, the premium is $19.99 monthly or $119.99 annually. But if you want to access all of Yousician’s (premium plus) instruments the price is $29.99 per month or $179.99 per year.

What do long-time users think? 

With both Fender Play and Yousician having their good and bad sides, consumer opinion is divided.

Yousician has had several ups and downs during its existence, so it has met many different criticisms from customers. 

 

 

According to many beginners, this app is worth trying because of its price and also the well-organized lessons, although they are nothing better than other guitar lessons platforms.

 

If you are not sold on Fender Play or Yousician, here are the alternatives

Fender Play and Yousician are a portable fun way of learning guitar.

But they are not the best.

Few proven online guitar lessons sites deserve to be mentioned.

  • JustinGuitar

When it comes to quality, program, and price, JustinGuitar is the best out there.

Justin Sandercoe is the founder of this site and the primary guitar teacher.

His knowledge and delivery is a great learning experience for any guitarist, especially beginners.

And when it comes to the price, JustinGuitar is free, so there is no harm in checking it out.

  • JamPlay

One from the top. JamPlay provides over 4 000 HD quality lessons from 73 guitar teachers.

It includes a vast song library, a bunch of guitar lessons, especially for beginners, as well as tips and tricks, which could be useful to everyone. 

There are three types of membership, monthly ($19.99), quarterly ($49.99) and annually ($159.99) plus seven days of a free trial.

Where do we go now? 

The most important thing is to learn how to play guitar while having fun.

That’s something that every learning platform is trying to provide, but the only one can be at the top. Plus it’s worth noting the top choice might not be the right choice for everyone. 

In this shootout, the winner is probably Yousician, because of its unique approach and program.

Sorry Fender Play.

But runner up is not that bad.